North Northamptonshire Council was entitled to refuse a freedom of information request for the files behind an unlicensed dog sales prosecution on the ground that reviewing around 2,700 documents for exemptions would impose a grossly oppressive burden, the Information Commission has ruled, while criticising the council for only raising the point once the regulator had begun investigating.
The request, made in July 2025, sought the investigation reports, internal communications over a 12-month period, the evidence gathered and any post-case reviews relating to an investigation by the council's predecessor, East Northamptonshire Council, which led to a prosecution at Wellingborough Magistrates' Court in October 2019. The investigation was carried out under the Animal Welfare (Licensing of Activities Involving Animals) (England) Regulations 2018.
The council disclosed some material in response to the request for post-case reviews and press releases but withheld the rest under section 30(1), which covers investigations and proceedings conducted by public authorities, and section 42(1), legal professional privilege.
It maintained that position at internal review in October 2025. Only after the complainant took the matter to the Commission did the council say it wished to rely instead on section 14(1), arguing that compliance would be grossly oppressive.
The council told the Commission its searches had identified around 500 to 600 hardcopy documents and about 2,100 electronic documents. It estimated that an officer would need an average of five minutes to read each document and consider the relevant exemptions, putting the work at more than 200 hours, or around seven working weeks for one officer.
The decision notice sets out the Commission's established approach. Burden is ordinarily a matter for section 12, under which a local authority can refuse a request where the cost of compliance would exceed £450 or 18 hours of officer time, but that provision cannot be used for the cost of considering exemptions or redacting exempt material.
Section 14(1) can cover that work, but the notice says the threshold is high and an authority is most likely to succeed where a substantial volume of information has been requested, it has real concerns about exempt material which it can substantiate, and the exempt material cannot easily be isolated because it is scattered through the records.
The Commission accepted that, as the material related to a statutory investigation that ended in a successful prosecution, a significant proportion of it was likely to need detailed consideration under sections 30(1) and 42(1), and that the council would also have to consider section 40(2) in relation to third-party personal data.
Officers with knowledge of both the subject matter and the exemptions would need to review the documents manually and at a granular level. The notice says that even if the council's 200-hour estimate were halved, the work would remain substantial, and while the section 12 limit was not treated as determinative, comparison with the 18-hour figure gave some context for the scale involved.
The Commission recognised that the request had a serious purpose and some public value, concerning the exercise of animal welfare enforcement powers and a prosecution for alleged unlawful activity. It found that value was reduced to some extent by information already in the public domain about the prosecution and its outcome, and that the request was very broad. Balancing those factors, it concluded the burden would be grossly oppressive.
The complainant argued that the council should have indicated what it could provide without disproportionate effort. The Commission rejected that argument on the basis that the council could only identify disclosable material by first considering the exemptions, which would impose the same burden that section 14(1) is designed to avoid, so there was no practicable advice and assistance it could offer under section 16.
The council was nonetheless found to have breached section 17(5), which requires an authority relying on section 14(1) to issue its refusal within 20 working days, because it did not invoke the provision until the Commission's investigation. Under "Other matters", the Commission said the council had failed to identify the breadth and complexity of the information requested and had issued a deficient response as a result.
Had it told the complainant about the volume of material and applied section 14(1) at the outset, the notice says, the matter might not have been escalated and significant resources could have been saved. The Commission added that a public authority "should not blindly apply exemptions", and that the Part II exemptions should only be applied once an authority is satisfied that neither section 12 nor section 14 applies.
No further steps were ordered. Either party may appeal to the First-tier Tribunal (Information Rights) within 28 days.
Decision notice IC-435246-M3K6 can be found here: https://ico.org.uk/media2/hbgc22ma/ic-435246-m3k6.pdf
