The London Borough of Hammersmith and Fulham breached the Environmental Information Regulations (EIR) by taking more than a year to release data on penalty charge notices issued at the Rivercourt Road bus gate, the Information Commission has found, after the council initially refused the request under the Freedom of Information Act and later accepted it should have been dealt with under the EIR.
The requester asked in May 2025 for the date enforcement of the bus gate began, the number of contraventions in each calendar month since, and a spreadsheet of every contravention on a specified date in April 2025 showing the PCN number, time of the contravention, date of issue and the recipient's postcode.
The requester noted that PCN numbers are council-generated codes that cannot identify a living person and that a postcode covers 20 to 30 buildings housing more than 50 people.
The council responded in June 2025 that the information was exempt under section 22(1) of FOIA, which covers information intended for future publication. The requester sought an internal review, pointing out that the specific information requested was not the same as that due to be published and that other authorities released PCN data on request. The council upheld its position in July 2025 and the requester complained to the Commission in September.
Under regulation 2(1)(c) of the EIR, environmental information includes information on measures and activities likely to affect the elements of the environment. The Commission found that the PCN data concerned the enforcement of a traffic management restriction, a trial of a smart filter on Rivercourt Road, and so was information on such a measure. Regulation 5(2) requires environmental information to be made available as soon as possible and no later than 20 working days after the request.
During the investigation the council accepted the request should have been considered under the EIR. It did not seek to rely on any EIR exception and disclosed information to the requester on 25 June 2026, more than 13 months after the request was made. The requester then raised what the notice describes as extensive concerns about inconsistencies in the council's responses, and the Commission went back to the council on several occasions over the accuracy and scope of what had been provided. Further information and explanations followed on 24 July 2026 and again on 4 September 2026, the latter including clarification of omissions in the labelling of the data.
The requester accepted the truncated postcodes supplied but pointed out that, because the council had not disclosed the information when first asked, a significant amount of postcode data had since been deleted under its retention policy. The council told the Commission that while its parking services privacy notice says information may be kept for six years, that period is to allow it to chase unpaid fines, and it does not retain personal details such as postcodes once a fine has been settled. The Commission did not consider whether the council was entitled to withhold the information at the time of the request, since everything still held had ultimately been disclosed.
The Commission found a breach of regulation 5(2) for the late provision of the information but required no further steps. Under "Other matters" it noted that the request had specified "Sunday 4 April" when 4 April 2025 was a Friday, and considered it reasonable for the council to act on the date rather than the day of the week, although it said the council should have gone back to the requester to clarify before responding and should bear this in mind when handling similar inaccuracies in future. The requester could make a fresh request for 6 April 2025.
The Commission acknowledged that the council had assisted by revisiting the request on numerous occasions but said it was concerned the repeated revisions were needed because of the council's own errors, which had prolonged the case. It asked the council to consider how to make PCN information more readily accessible or retrievable to assist in responding to future requests.
