Info Gov

The First-tier Tribunal has refused a costs application against the Information Commission arising from a successful appeal over a request about a police escort for Taylor Swift, with the First Tier Tribunal finding that neither the decision notice nor the regulator's defence of the appeal was unreasonable.

In Edward Williams v Information Commission [2026] UKFTT 1550 (GRC, the claimant, who represented himself, claimed three hours at £19 an hour, a total of £57. He told the hearing his main aim was to establish the standard expected of decision notices and that the money was secondary.

Williams had asked the Attorney General's Office on 13 October 2024 for information it held about the escort. Decision notice IC-349620-N4R2 of 14 May 2025 upheld the AGO's refusal to confirm or deny under section 35(3) of the Freedom of Information Act 2000, which rested on the Law Officers' advice exemption in section 35(1)(c).

A panel led by Judge Snelson allowed the appeal on 16 December 2025 and gave the AGO 28 days to issue a fresh response, finding that the regulator had fallen into the same error as the department.

Snelson refused the costs application on the papers on 6 February 2026. Upper Tribunal Judge Wikeley set that refusal aside on 8 June 2026 because it had not addressed rule 10(1)(c), and sent the application back for both limbs to be considered afresh.

Costs in the General Regulatory Chamber are governed by section 29 of the Tribunals, Courts and Enforcement Act 2007 and rule 10 of the Tribunal Procedure (First-tier Tribunal) (General Regulatory Chamber) Rules 2009. Rule 10(1)(b) permits an order where a party has acted unreasonably in bringing, defending or conducting proceedings. Rule 10(1)(c) permits an order where the decision, direction or order under appeal was itself unreasonable. In Kirkham v Information Commissioner [2018] UKUT 65 (AAC) the Upper Tribunal held that costs orders are exceptional and that the onus lies on the applicant.

Williams argued that the decision notice had simply endorsed the AGO's response without scrutiny and that the appeal should not have been defended. He also contended that the burden of showing reasonableness lay with the regulator. Harris rejected that submission and followed Kirkham.

On rule 10(1)(c), Harris accepted the description offered by the Commission's own counsel, Eric Metcalfe, that paragraph 26 of the decision notice was "infelicitous" and could have been better explained. Williams conceded that the statement in that paragraph was factually accurate. Harris held that using similar wording across decision notices is not improper, because the regulator may deploy its resources efficiently, and judged the notice against what was known when it was issued.

On rule 10(1)(b), Harris applied the principles in Financial Solutions (Euro) Ltd v FCA [2020] UKUT 0243 (TCC). The regulator's case had not been one that was plainly bound to fail, no strike-out had been ordered, and there was no vexatious conduct or improper motive. Being wrong on an issue did not make the defence unreasonable.

Because the threshold was not met, questions of discretion and quantum did not arise.

 

 

Also in this section

Nov 17, 2026

Reviewing 2,700 documents for exemptions would be grossly oppressive burden, says Information Commission

North Northamptonshire Council was entitled to refuse a freedom of information request for the files behind an unlicensed dog sales prosecution on the ground that reviewing around 2,700 documents for exemptions would impose a grossly oppressive burden, the Information Commission has ruled, while criticising the council for only raising the point once the regulator had begun investigating.
Nov 12, 2026

Council wrongly handled bus gate PCN request under FOIA, Information Commission finds

The London Borough of Hammersmith and Fulham breached the Environmental Information Regulations (EIR) by taking more than a year to release data on penalty charge notices issued at the Rivercourt Road bus gate, the Information Commission has found, after the council initially refused the request under the Freedom of Information Act and later accepted it should have been dealt with under the EIR.
Nov 11, 2026

ICO serves university with information notice over FOI performance data after mailbox auto-reply blamed staffing

The Information Commission (ICO) has served an information notice on the University of Manchester under section 51 of the Freedom of Information Act 2000, giving the university 30 days to hand over 12 months of request-handling performance data it has repeatedly failed to provide, after the regulator found the university's information rights mailboxes returning an automated reply saying they were…