The Biometrics and Surveillance Camera Commissioner, Professor William Webster, has welcomed the Government's plan to legislate on facial recognition but said its consultation response leaves key questions about governance, oversight and enforcement unanswered.
In a statement published on 17 November, Webster said the Home Office response points in a clear direction without supplying the detail. Biometric surveillance, including live facial recognition, is intrusive, he said, and interferes with freedom of movement, expression and assembly and with privacy. "Clear legislation and effective safeguards are essential to mitigate these risks," he said.
The Commissioner listed seven matters he said were unclear,as follows:
- which governance, accountability and oversight provisions will sit in primary legislation and which in the new code
- how necessity and proportionality will work in practice
- who will rule on the efficacy and acceptability of individual technologies
- what meaningful oversight will involve
- how national technical and operational standards will be developed
- how compliance in the commercial sector will be enforced
- whether the new oversight body will have adequate resources
The Home Office's response to the consultation, published on 4 November, committed the government to a new statutory framework covering live and retrospective facial recognition, other biometric and inferential technologies, and overt surveillance tools. Police, other law enforcement organisations and other public bodies would fall within scope, the last only for law enforcement and limited safeguarding purposes. A single independent oversight body would take on and extend existing oversight functions, with powers to monitor compliance and enforce standards.
Police use of facial recognition currently relies on common law powers, Part 3 of the Data Protection Act 2018, the Human Rights Act 1998, the Equality Act 2010 and the Surveillance Camera Code of Practice issued under the Protection of Freedoms Act 2012.
The government's response says the new framework will draw on the 2012 Act's principles and on the statutory rules for DNA and fingerprints. A separate code of practice is planned for private sector use in preventing and detecting crime, which is already subject to data protection law.
He welcomed the proposal to give the oversight body compliance powers and repeated his position that oversight must cover audit, inspection and compliance. He asked for more detail on those powers and on whether the body's resources and expertise will match its remit. Coordination with other regulators will be needed to prevent duplication and gaps, he added.
Webster said live facial recognition deployments he has observed differ in practice from one police force to another, and that the framework could support consistent compliance with national standards, building on those already promoted under the Surveillance Camera Code of Practice.
He also said Parliament must be able to bring further technologies into the framework later. He expects live facial recognition to be built into existing camera networks, body-worn video and drones, alongside developments in AI-driven video analytics.
Under the Government's proposals, the seriousness of the crime would not be the only test for deployment, and legislation would set the minimum police rank able to authorise use. Public participation in oversight would become a statutory requirement for forces and the oversight body.
Webster said he looks forward to the full detail when the Police Reform Bill is laid before Parliament, and added that binding rules are needed urgently as use of the technologies is spreading quickly.
