The Information Commission has ordered Surrey County Council to disclose information about the elective home education process it followed for Sara Sharif, ruling that the council could not rely on the breach of confidence exemption and was not entitled to withhold the material in full as personal data.
Surrey refused it under section 40(2) and section 41 of the Freedom of Information Act 2000 (FOIA), which respectively protect third-party personal data and information provided in confidence. Both are absolute exemptions, meaning that the standard FOIA public interest test does not apply.
The unnamed complainant argued that the Council could have provided extracts, summaries or redacted versions of the information rather than withholding it in full. They also argued that the public interest in understanding the circumstances of Sara’s de-registration from school outweighs the public interest in maintaining the exemptions.
The Information Commission's Decision notice IC-428260-N3X1, dated 4 November 2026, upheld the complaint on both points. On section 41, the Commission concluded the exemption was not engaged at all. On section 40(2), it found the council could not use the exemption to withhold everything requested.
A confidential annex to the notice identifies the material that must now be released. The published summary sets out no further reasoning and does not say how much of the withheld information falls within the annex.
Section 41 of FOIA exempts information obtained from another person where disclosure would amount to an actionable breach of confidence. Section 40(2) exempts the personal data of third parties where disclosure would contravene the data protection principles.
An information notice bearing the same case reference was issued to the council on 2 September 2026, two months before the decision.
Sara was withdrawn from school in April 2023 to be home educated. A child safeguarding practice review published in November 2025 found that a home visit required by Surrey's policy within ten working days of withdrawal did not happen. When the council's home education team did attempt a visit, on 7 August 2023, it went to the family's former address. The review made 15 recommendations, and the council said it was deeply sorry for the failings identified.
