The Information Commission’s Office (ICO) has concluded that the National Trust is a public authority under the Environmental Information Regulations 2004 (EIR), following a complaint over a refused information request.
The dispute centred on a request seeking all documents, internal policies, procedures or protocols governing or affecting how the National Trust has managed or is managing access for commercial groups to the Pembrokeshire coastline.
The National Trust owns nearly 250,000 hectares of farmland as well as more than 500 historic places. Its property portfolio covers around 780 to 890 miles of coast, according to figures released by the charity.
It refused the request in June 2025, stating that, as an independent charity and membership organisation, it was not subject to the EIR.
It also provided a link to a previous decision notice in which the Commissioner had concluded that the National Trust was not a public authority for the purposes of the regulations.
The complainant subsequently contacted the Commissioner to challenge the way their request had been handled.
They acknowledged the ICO’s previous decision, issued in March 2022, but argued that the National Trust’s status should be reconsidered because the Commissioner had not seen the 2025 Pembrokeshire Coasteering Concordat when reaching that conclusion.
The Concordat, they explained, demonstrates that the National Trust “exercises its statutory by-law powers and jointly regulates commercial access to the coastline with Pembrokeshire Coast National Park Authority and Pembrokeshire County Council”.
They further argued that, through the Concordat, the National Trust “imposes binding conditions on third-party operators, enforces compliance through sanctions and restricts activities for conservation and public-safety reasons”.
In a decision notice, the Commissioner said that, although he had not seen the requested information, he was satisfied from the wording of the request that, if held, it would constitute environmental information under regulation 2(1) of the EIR.
Turning to the National Trust’s status, the Commissioner considered whether it was entrusted with services of public interest and vested with “special powers” to carry out those services. This dual test was identified in Fish Legal & Emily Shirley v IC C-279/12.
Having reviewed the powers conferred on the National Trust by legislation, the Commissioner concluded that several went beyond those available to ordinary private landowners.
The powers included the ability to make and enforce byelaws, and the power for a National Trust officer to exclude someone from its land or property if they have committed an offence by contravening the byelaws.
The Commissioner ultimately found that it was satisfied that the National Trust is entrusted with services of public interest and is vested with special powers for the purpose of carrying out those services.
"The National Trust therefore satisfies the dual test identified in Fish Legal and is a public authority for the purposes of regulation 2(2)(c) of the EIR," the decision notice said.
