The Information Commission (ICO) has served an information notice on the University of Manchester under section 51 of the Freedom of Information Act 2000, giving the university 30 days to hand over 12 months of request-handling performance data it has repeatedly failed to provide, after the regulator found the university's information rights mailboxes returning an automated reply saying they were temporarily unable to respond because of staffing issues.
The notice sets out how the matter came to light through a data protection complaint rather than an FOI case. On discovering the auto-reply, the Commission asked for urgent follow-up and held an engagement meeting with the university on 26 August 2026. The university supplied some but not all of the performance data requested beforehand.
The Commission then asked for 12 months of data by 16 September, granted the university's request for an extension to the end of that week, and received nothing. A chaser sent on 8 October went unanswered and the data remained outstanding when the notice was issued.
The ICO said that it acknowledged the university's candour and that similarly sized authorities would also struggle in the circumstances described, but that the qualitative information provided does not give an accurate picture of the challenges or the progress being made. Without good-quality performance data, it added, it cannot determine whether the university is meeting its obligations.
Section 51 of FOIA allows the Commission to require a public authority to furnish information it needs to assess compliance with the Act, and regulation 18 of the Environmental Information Regulations 2004 confers equivalent powers under the EIR. The Commission's stated concern is that the university may be failing to comply with sections 1 and 10 of FOIA and regulation 5 of the EIR by not responding to requests within 20 working days, and that its practices may not conform with chapters 4 and 5 of the section 45 code of practice and chapters IV and XII of the EIR code because internal reviews appear to be taking longer than 40 working days.
The university must return a completed copy of the Commission's standardised data collection tool, with every row and column populated from its systems, by 3 December 2026. Data may be recorded by financial or academic year provided the period for each field is clear, and the most recent figures must be accurate as at the date they are supplied.
If the university fails to comply, the Commission may certify the failure in writing to the High Court under section 54 of FOIA, where it may be dealt with as a contempt of court. The university has 28 days from the date the notice was sent to appeal to the First-tier Tribunal (Information Rights).
The notice is one of the first the regulator has published under its new name following the Data (Use and Access) Act 2025, which replaced the Information Commissioner with the Information Commission as a corporate body. It continues the approach the ICO developed over recent years of using section 51 notices and the data collection tool to put authorities with suspected backlogs on a formal footing, with enforcement notices and practice recommendations following where the data confirms sustained non-compliance.
