Info Gov

The First‑tier Tribunal has struck out an appeal by the London Borough of Havering after the authority failed to comply with case management directions and did not attend a scheduled Case Compliance Hearing.

In a decision issued on 14 January 2026, Judge Harris ruled that the appeal - lodged in January 2025 against an Information Commissioner’s decision notice - should be struck out under rule 8(3)(a) of the Tribunal Procedure (First‑tier Tribunal) (General Regulatory Chamber) Rules 2009.

Havering had been ordered on 11 November 2025 to provide the Tribunal with a hearing bundle by 5th January 2026. According to the decision, the council failed to do so and did not offer any explanation for the non‑compliance.

The same directions required the authority to attend or be represented at a Case Compliance Hearing on 13 January 2026. Judge Harris noted that the council again failed to engage and attempts by the Tribunal clerk to contact the authority on the morning of the hearing were unsuccessful.

Both the Information Commissioner and the second respondent, Kevin Johnson, attended the hearing.

Judge Harris said it was in the interests of justice to proceed despite the council’s absence, given the lack of any explanation for its non‑attendance.

The judge concluded that Havering’s failure to file the required bundle and its failure to attend the hearing amounted to clear grounds for striking out the appeal.

The appeal was therefore struck out in full, with the Tribunal summarily determining all issues against the council.

The London Borough of Havering has been contacted for comment.

Also in this section

Jun 10, 2026

Tribunal backs Insolvency Service's refusal to confirm whether it holds complaint response

A requester who used FOIA to seek a copy of the response to her own complaint has lost her appeal, after the First-tier Tribunal confirmed that section 40(5A) entitled the Insolvency Service to neither confirm nor deny holding the information, not least because the appellant herself had repeatedly insisted the material related to her personally.
Jun 09, 2026

MoD Wins FOI Battle Over Court Martial Disclosure

The Ministry of Defence has successfully defended a freedom of information appeal brought by a former RAF serviceman who sought disclosure of investigators' material and unused evidence from a court martial case in which he pleaded guilty to six charges of misapplication of service property.
Jun 09, 2026

Tribunal overturns ICO ruling on Bounce Back Loan FOI request linked to MP

The First-tier Tribunal has ordered the Department for Business and Trade to confirm or deny whether it holds information about Bounce Back Loans connected to companies previously owned by a sitting MP, after finding that the Information Commissioner wrongly upheld a neither confirm nor deny response.
Jun 08, 2026

Tribunal rules ONS wrongly branded "Black Lives Matter" FOI requests vexatious

The First-tier Tribunal has ruled that the Office for National Statistics (ONS) unlawfully refused a series of Freedom of Information requests as vexatious, finding that a former employee who sought internal records relating to a controversial "Black Lives Matter" staff email had a genuine and legitimate purpose in making them.

InfoGov Masthead Newsletter 800